In her column (“Pointless preservation,” Oct. 8), Amelia Meyer refers to the restoration of the Lawn and Range rooms as “pointless preservation.” Public and private institutions in possession of historic structures must make difficult choices about how to balance the demands of preservation with other objectives.
Meyer admits that “maintaining the integrity of the buildings” is “an acceptable undertaking worth the cost,” but it follows that the use of authentic building materials and methods is a part of such maintenance. The preservation of the Academical Village — a World Heritage Site — demands sensitivity to the craftsmanship of these buildings. The replacement of decayed or inappropriate window sashes (window framing, not curtains) is certainly expensive, but such costly repairs for landmark buildings are necessary rather than pointless.
It is disappointing that Meyer suggests that the preservation of the Lawn and Range rooms evokes feelings of a time when “segregation and gender discrimination were openly endorsed.” Such a charge could be leveled at nearly all old buildings.
Philip Herrington
GSAS III
Read More
BAKER, FRIDLEY, LIEU: We should re-examine Inclusive Access textbooks on Grounds
By Susannah Baker , Chloe Fridley and Brighton Lieu | April 11, 2025This appearance gives a fooling impression that Inclusive Access is the cheapest, best option for students, when in reality, the program is misleading in cost, accessibility and privacy.
OBITUARY: John Thomas Casteen III passes away at 81
By Elizabeth Ingeborg Casteen and John T. Casteen IV | March 19, 2025Casteen may be best remembered as the founder of AccessUVA, a scholarship program to support undergraduate students whose qualifications were excellent, but whose families would be hard pressed to afford college tuition.
LETTER: A letter to the U.Va. community from the A.N.G.E.L.S. Society
By A.N.G.E.L.S. Society | March 18, 2025Each student, employee, faculty member and University and Charlottesville community member deserves to feel safe, a feeling that has been uprooted in the past few weeks.
