Ben Chrisinger protests the Civility Project (“Cultural differences,” 3/16/2009), an effort to provide students with behavioral guidelines for the twenty-first century, because he fears that such a project will “alienate” foreign students. He says that “the value that an individual places on a behavior or custom is so utterly dependent on their background,” that to impose those values on others is illegitimate.
Chrisinger is wrong on both accounts. First, he insults foreign students by suggesting that they are so sensitive. We all know better. Students from abroad are frequently the most resolute among us. They are brave; otherwise they would not travel so far from home. Further, students study abroad partially so that they can learn about foreign cultures. Chrisinger would deny foreign students what they come all the way to Virginia for.
Chrisinger also errs in his assessment of the moral legitimacy of imposing manners. Manners are an expression of inestimable human worth from one person to the next. They give order and meaning to our daily interactions. The goal of maintaining manners is uniform across a wide variety of cultures. Even if the expression of human worth differs from place to place, its justification remains the same.
So surely we are justified in maintaining a system of manners. Such a system must be uniform within a given community, or one person will not be able to know what another is trying to express. Suggesting that we should not ‘impose’ manners on foreign students, then, is akin to suggesting that we should not ‘impose’ language on them. What right have we to tell foreign students that they need to speak our language?
Read More
BAKER, FRIDLEY, LIEU: We should re-examine Inclusive Access textbooks on Grounds
By Susannah Baker , Chloe Fridley and Brighton Lieu | April 11, 2025This appearance gives a fooling impression that Inclusive Access is the cheapest, best option for students, when in reality, the program is misleading in cost, accessibility and privacy.
OBITUARY: John Thomas Casteen III passes away at 81
By Elizabeth Ingeborg Casteen and John T. Casteen IV | March 19, 2025Casteen may be best remembered as the founder of AccessUVA, a scholarship program to support undergraduate students whose qualifications were excellent, but whose families would be hard pressed to afford college tuition.
LETTER: A letter to the U.Va. community from the A.N.G.E.L.S. Society
By A.N.G.E.L.S. Society | March 18, 2025Each student, employee, faculty member and University and Charlottesville community member deserves to feel safe, a feeling that has been uprooted in the past few weeks.
