The Cavalier Daily
Serving the University Community Since 1890

Brooks, Haidt talk morals

New York Times columnist, Psychology prof. discuss nation

David Brooks, an op-ed columnist for The New York Times, spoke yesterday with Psychology Prof. Jonathan Haidt at a talk hosted by the Batten School called "Morality and Politics: The Challenge of Public Policymaking."

Haidt opened the discussion with a 25-minute presentation about his book, "The Righteous Mind: Why Good People are Divided by Politics and Religion," which was released last week. Haidt outlined the key points of his book, which describes the origins of ethics and the manner in which they affect political discourse.

He said the United States' moral diversity is created by six values: fairness, proportionality, liberty, authority, sanctity and care.

Haidt said conservatives and liberals have ethical foundations which emphasize the importance of different morals. While conservatives consider a little of all six morals, liberals tend to emphasize fairness, care and authority, he said.

"Morality binds us into ideological teams that fight each other [and] blinds us to the fact that each team is composed of good people who have something to say," Haidt said.

Brooks followed Haidt's presentation, critiquing Haidt's work. Despite his disagreements with parts of the book, Brooks said it offered a great foundation for analyzing politics, providing "shafts of insight into how our moral drives are dividing us."

Brooks, however, said he was hesitant to reduce the interplay of morality and politics to specific morals divided along partisan lines. He said the morals Haidt attributed to conservatives and liberals cannot fully explain political changes which disrupt the moral foundations of parties.

Public policy could be improved by taking into account moral, social and spiritual concerns, Brooks said, instead of focusing on economic issues, as is the tendency in modern politics.

A thirty-minute question and answer session followed Brooks' critique, which allowed Brooks and Haidt to apply their theoretical concepts to current politicians and public policy.

Local Savings

Comments

Latest Video

Latest Podcast

With the Virginia Quarterly Review’s 100th Anniversary approaching Executive Director Allison Wright and Senior Editorial Intern Michael Newell-Dimoff, reflect on the magazine’s last hundred years, their own experiences with VQR and the celebration for the magazine’s 100th anniversary!